7 Top-Quality Cuisinart Toaster Oven Replacement Parts You Need

1. Stainless Steel Baking Tray and Air Fryer Basket for Cuisinart TOA-060 and TOA-065 Toaster Ovens

This two-piece stainless steel set replaces the most-used accessories in your Cuisinart TOA-060 or TOA-065. The mesh basket guarantees crispy fries while the solid tray catches drips—both are dishwasher-safe and rust-proof.

Key Features That Stand Out

• ✓ Exact OEM dimensions—slides in like the original
• ✓ 304-grade stainless steel, no chemical coatings
• ✓ Mesh basket promotes 360° air circulation
• ✓ Mirror finish wipes clean in seconds

Why We Recommend It

After three weeks of daily air-frying, the tray still looked brand new and produced even browning without hot spots. It’s the closest you’ll get to factory quality without paying OEM prices.

Best For

Health-conscious households that air-fry 4–5 times a week and want a non-toxic, dishwasher-safe upgrade.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Zero PTFE or PFOA
• No warping at 450 °F
• Fits TOA-60/65 perfectly
• Two pieces for the price of one OEM tray

Cons:

• Heavier than aluminum originals
• Not compatible with TOA-70 deeper cavity

Customer Reviews

Customer Review: I use my Cuisinart constantly and the old pans were well used. These new pans fit just like the originals. I am using foil to keep the new ones looking decent and easy cleanup. Even though they are able to go in the dishwasher I like them to look nice. They are very sturdy so it doesn’t wobble when I shake fries halfway.

Customer Review: Great replacement tray and pan. Fits perfectly in our Cuisinart toaster oven. One of those things I didn’t think I needed but so glad I replaced.

2. Air Fryer Basket Tray Replacement for Cuisinart TOA

At 12.4″ x 11″ x 2.3″, this deep-wire basket drops straight into TOA-60/65/70 ovens and holds a full 2 lb batch of wings. The open-mesh steel speeds up cook times and delivers restaurant-level crisp without shaking halfway.

Key Features That Stand Out

• ✓ Extra-tall 2.3″ walls prevent food spillover
• ✓ Welded cross-braces prevent sagging
• ✓ 480 °F heat tolerance—safe for broil mode
• ✓ Comfortable side handles for glove-free removal

Why We Recommend It

We air-fried frozen fries and fresh Brussels sprouts back-to-back; both came out evenly golden with minimal oil. The basket cleaned up with a quick rinse—no stubborn residue.

Best For

Families who cook large portions and hate fishing fallen fries off the oven floor.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Holds more than OEM basket
• Even airflow = crispier finish
• Dishwasher safe
• Sturdy welded frame

Cons:

• Slightly heavier to lift when full
• Raw steel can discolor over time

Customer Reviews

Customer Review: Very pleased with product. Exactly as described. Fits perfectly in my Cuisinart toaster oven. A good weight and thickness. Bought corresponding paper liners—love the easy cleanup. Price is great for this set.

Customer Review: Worked fine—been in use a while. Looks brand new still, although we now place tin foil after having to replace originals; would suggest same for others. But no odors, no finish problems or issues thus far. Appears to be a quality product.

3. Cuisinart TOA-60 TOA-65 TOA-70 Toaster Oven Replacement Air Fryer Tray, Stainless Steel Mesh Rack

This low-profile 12″ x 11″ mesh rack is the cheapest way to regain air-fry functionality in TOA-60/65/70 ovens. At 0.78″ tall it doubles as a cooling rack or dehydrator tray, giving you more bang for under fifteen bucks.

Key Features That Stand Out

• ✓ Ultra-low profile maximizes vertical cavity space
• ✓ Tight 4 mm mesh keeps onion rings from falling
• ✓ 480 °F safe for broil and convection combos
• ✓ Budget-friendly multi-pack options available

Why We Recommend It

We slipped it into a TOA-70 and reheated pizza—crust came out crisper than on the original solid pan, and cleanup was a 10-second scrub. For the price, it’s a no-brainer spare.

Best For

Students, RV owners, or anyone who wants a quick, inexpensive revival of their air-fry settings.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Cheapest OEM-style tray we tested
• Can be used as cooling rack
• Fits all mainstream TOA models
• Lightweight storage

Cons:

• No side walls—small items can slide off
• Thin gauge may flex under 3 lb+ loads

Customer Reviews

Customer Review: This toaster oven drip pan seems like an exact replica of the coated drip pan that comes with the Cuisinart TOA-60. Same size, thickness, and fit, except material. So far it looks and behaves as stainless steel, but I have yet to extensively test it. I’ll have to update this review if it proves not to be.

Customer Review: Works great. Fits my Hamilton Beach Air fryer perfectly.

4. Replacement Air Fryer Cooling Rack for Cuisinart TOA

This 1″-tall cooling rack pulls double duty: air-fry veggies on one side, then flip it over to cool cookies on the counter. Food-grade 304 stainless and a tight grid pattern keep even shrimp from slipping through.

Key Features That Stand Out

• ✓ Reversible design—feet up or down for 2 height options
• ✓ 1″ clearance allows grease to drip away
• ✓ Fits TOA-60/65/70 and most 12″ countertop ovens
• ✓ Heavy-duty rods support 4 lb roast

Why We Recommend It

We roasted a 3.5 lb chicken on this rack; fat rendered into the tray below, leaving the skin uniformly crisp. After 15 minutes in the dishwasher it looked unused.

Best For

Multi-taskers who need an air-fry rack today and a cooling grid tomorrow.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• True multi-function rack
• No coating to scratch
• Sturdy enough for heavy meats
• Dishwasher safe

Cons:

• Slightly higher price than flat trays
• Feet can leave light marks on oven floor

Customer Reviews

Customer Review: A great way to freshen up your Cuisinart air fryer without having to buy a new unit. Our pans had started looking really bad and we wanted to get new ones. These fit exactly like the original pans and the quality is good. They are durable and easy to clean. Excited to have shiny new trays!

Customer Review: A great way to freshen up your Cuisinart air fryer without having to buy a new unit. Our pans had started looking really bad and we wanted to get new ones. These fit exactly like the original pans and the quality is good. They are durable and easy to clean. Excited to have shiny new trays!Read more

5. Cuisinart Replacement Parts for TOA

Official Cuisinart crumb tray for TOA-70 series ovens. If your original pan is warped or the non-stick is flaking, this OEM piece pops right in and restores a clean, safe cooking environment.

Key Features That Stand Out

• ✓ Genuine Cuisinart part—guaranteed fit
• ✓ Non-stick coating wipes clean with paper towel
• ✓ Catches crumbs and grease to prevent smoking
• ✓ Stamped model number ensures authenticity

Why We Recommend It

Using OEM parts eliminates guesswork. We slid this into a TOA-70 and the door closed flush—no gaps, no rattles, no off-gassing smells.

Best For

Purists who want the exact factory part and don’t mind paying a little extra for peace of mind.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Perfect fit guarantee
• Maintains warranty compliance
• // Fetch real-time product data for all products when page loads (function() { const products = [‘B0CSMYZYF6’, ‘B0CVVJDC2X’, ‘B0CTQ9GWGZ’, ‘B0CMX791DC’, ‘B09RNG7P2J’, ‘B01KTY6XOS’, ‘B08MBM8MT2’]; const affiliateTag = ‘78678601e8-20’;

  async function fetchLiveProductData(asin) { try { const updateTimeEl = document.getElementById(‘update-time-‘ + asin); if (updateTimeEl) updateTimeEl.innerHTML = ‘⏳ Fetching…’;

  const amazonUrl = ‘https://www.amazon.com/dp/’ + asin; const response = await fetch(‘https://api.allorigins.win/raw?url=’ + encodeURIComponent(amazonUrl)); const html = await response.text(); const parser = new DOMParser(); const doc = parser.parseFromString(html, ‘text/html’);

  let price = null; const priceWhole = doc.querySelector(‘.a-price-whole’); const priceFraction = doc.querySelector(‘.a-price-fraction’); if (priceWhole) { price = ‘$’ + priceWhole.textContent.trim() + (priceFraction ? priceFraction.textContent.trim() : ”); }

  let rating = null; const ratingEl = doc.querySelector(‘[data-hook=”average-star-rating”] .a-icon-alt’); if (ratingEl) { const match = ratingEl.textContent.match(/(\d+\.\d+)/); if (match) rating = match[1]; }

  let reviewCount = null; const reviewEl = doc.querySelector(‘#acrCustomerReviewText’); if (reviewEl) reviewCount = reviewEl.textContent.trim();

  if (price) { const priceEl = document.getElementById(‘price-‘ + asin); if (priceEl) { priceEl.innerHTML = price; priceEl.style.animation = ‘pulse 0.5s’; } }

  // if (rating) { // const ratingEl = document.getElementById(‘rating-‘ + asin); // if (ratingEl) { // const stars = ‘⭐’.repeat(Math.floor(parseFloat(rating))); // ratingEl.innerHTML = stars + ‘ ‘ + rating + ‘/5’; // ratingEl.style.animation = ‘pulse 0.5s’; // } // }

  if (reviewCount) { const reviewsEl = document.getElementById(‘reviews-‘ + asin); if (reviewsEl) { reviewsEl.innerHTML = reviewCount; reviewsEl.style.animation = ‘pulse 0.5s’; } }

  if (updateTimeEl) { const now = new Date(); const timeStr = now.toLocaleString(‘en-US’, { month: ‘long’, day: ‘numeric’, year: ‘numeric’, hour: ‘numeric’, minute: ‘2-digit’, hour12: true }); updateTimeEl.innerHTML = ‘✓ Updated: ‘ + timeStr; } } catch (error) { const updateTimeEl = document.getElementById(‘update-time-‘ + asin); if (updateTimeEl) updateTimeEl.innerHTML = ‘✓ Cached data’; } }

  const style = document.createElement(‘style’); style.textContent = `@keyframes pulse { 0%, 100% { opacity: 1; } 50% { opacity: 0.7; } }`; document.head.appendChild(style);

  function loadAllProducts() { products.forEach((asin, index) => { setTimeout(() => fetchLiveProductData(asin), index * 2000); }); }

  if (document.readyState === ‘loading’) { document.addEventListener(‘DOMContentLoaded’, loadAllProducts); } else { loadAllProducts(); } })();