When your Mr. Coffee carafe cracks, chips, or simply wears out, finding the right Mr Coffee carafe replacement is essential to keep your morning brew routine running smoothly. With so many third-party and OEM options on the market, compatibility, durability, and value can vary significantly. Whether you own a PLD12, SK12, RF, or MSX series model, choosing a high-quality replacement ensures safe, reliable, and long-lasting performance. In this comprehensive guide, we’ve tested and reviewed the top 7 Mr Coffee carafe replacements to help you make an informed decision—no matter your budget or machine model.
Quick Product Comparison
Our Top 7 Mr Coffee Carafe Replacement Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
1. Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Glass Coffee Carafe Replacement for PLD12, SK12, SK13 Models
This official-style Mr Coffee carafe replacement is engineered for precise compatibility with PLD12, SK12, and SK13 models, offering a seamless fit and reliable performance. Made from durable, heat-resistant glass, it’s designed to withstand daily brewing cycles while maintaining clarity and strength over time.
💡 Related:
coffee maker carafe replacements
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Exact OEM-style fit for PLD12, SK12, and SK13 series
✓ Heat-resistant borosilicate glass construction
✓ Dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning
✓ Clear cup markings for accurate water measurement
✓ Includes secure handle and lid compatibility
Why We Recommend It
This carafe delivers OEM-level quality at a fraction of the cost, making it our top pick for users seeking reliability and authenticity. Its precise engineering ensures no leaks, spills, or fit issues—perfect for restoring your coffee maker to like-new condition.
Best For
Owners of Mr. Coffee PLD12, SK12, or SK13 models who want a factory-grade replacement without paying premium prices.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Exact dimensional match for listed models
- High thermal shock resistance
- Easy to clean and maintain
- Affordable compared to original parts
Cons:
- Not compatible with RF or MSX series
- Lid not included (must reuse original)
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Perfect replacement for my Mr. Coffee machine. It arrived overnight and was a reasonable price.”
Customer Review: “Perfect replacement for my Mr. Coffee machine. It arrived overnight and was a reasonable price. Read more”
2. 12-Cup Glass Carafe Replacement for Mr. Coffee Models SK12, SK13, EHX23, JWX31, SJX23, SJX39
Designed for broad compatibility across multiple Mr. Coffee and Sunbeam models, this Mr Coffee carafe replacement offers excellent value and performance. Its robust glass build and ergonomic handle make it a favorite among users with EHX, JWX, or SJX series machines.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Fits SK12, SK13, EHX23, JWX31, SJX23, SJX39 and more
✓ Compatible with select Sunbeam 12-cup models
✓ Heat-resistant glass with reinforced rim
✓ Comfort-grip handle for safe pouring
✓ Dishwasher-safe top rack cleaning
Why We Recommend It
With wide model coverage and solid construction, this carafe stands out as our Editor’s Choice for versatility and durability. It’s ideal for households with older or less common Mr. Coffee units that still brew great coffee.
Best For
Users with EHX, JWX, or SJX series coffee makers looking for a reliable, multi-model compatible replacement.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Broad compatibility across multiple series
- Sturdy handle design
- Affordable price point
- Clear volume markings
Cons:
- May not fit newer RF or MSX models
- Glass thickness slightly less than OEM
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Fits my JWX31 perfectly! Much better than expected for the price.”
Customer Review: “Arrived quickly and works just like the original. Highly recommend for EHX owners.”
3. Glass Carafe Replacement Compatible with Mr Coffee 12 Cup Coffee Machine # RF, PC,SC,MMX,MSX, BVM…
This budget-friendly Mr Coffee carafe replacement delivers surprising quality for the price, supporting a wide range of RF, PC, SC, MMX, and MSX models. Made from BPA-free borosilicate glass, it resists cracking and clouding even with frequent use.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Compatible with RF, PC, SC, MMX, MSX, and BVM series
✓ 12-cup (1.8L) capacity with easy-read markings
✓ Includes bonus plastic coffee scoop
✓ Dishwasher-safe and BPA-free
✓ Close-grip handle for controlled pouring
Why We Recommend It
For under $20, this carafe offers exceptional value without sacrificing safety or functionality. It’s our Best Budget pick for cost-conscious buyers who refuse to compromise on essential features.
Best For
Students, renters, or anyone needing an affordable yet reliable replacement for RF or MSX series machines.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Extremely affordable
- Includes free coffee scoop
- Lightweight yet durable
- Fits many popular models
Cons:
- Handle may feel slightly flimsy
- Not compatible with SK or PLD series
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Good quality and fits our Mr. Coffee coffeemaker! It’s a little different from the original carafe, but it works fine and is well made. Good value. Would buy again.”
Customer Review: “I like the carafe. It is right size. It is easy to wipe clean with a paper towel.”
4. Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Glass Carafe Replacement for RF, LM, PC, and SC Series
Specifically engineered for RF, LM, PC, and SC series, this Mr Coffee carafe replacement features a sleek black handle and precision-fit design. Its dishwasher-safe glass ensures hassle-free maintenance and long-term clarity.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Exact fit for RF, LM, PC, and SC models only
✓ Stylish black handle with ergonomic grip
✓ Dishwasher-safe (top rack recommended)
✓ Heat-resistant glass construction
✓ Clear graduated cup measurements
Why We Recommend It
This carafe combines form and function, offering a modern look with reliable performance. It’s a great choice for users who want a direct OEM-style upgrade with improved aesthetics.
Best For
Owners of Mr. Coffee RF, LM, PC, or SC series seeking a stylish, exact-fit replacement.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Precise compatibility with listed series
- Modern black handle design
- Easy to clean
- Solid build quality
Cons:
- Limited to only four series
- Slightly higher price than generic options
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “This is the best substitute I could only imagine! I was doing the general cleaning in my house. So… my efforts to have everything shining were resulting in breaking the coffee pot. This one fits perfectly! My husband is even more happy than me.”
Customer Review: “Fit perfect. Great quality product that has lasted longer than the original.”
5. Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Replacement Carafe – Compatible with Mr. Coffee 12 Cup Machines, Glass Pot with…
Built for LMX, TP, MMX, and MSX series, this Mr Coffee carafe replacement features a streamlined design with convenient cup markings and a secure pour spout. Its borosilicate glass ensures resistance to thermal shock and daily wear.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Designed for LMX, TP, MMX, and MSX series
✓ Integrated cup measurement markings
✓ Smooth pouring spout minimizes drips
✓ Heat-resistant and shatter-resistant glass
✓ Comfortable, non-slip handle
Why We Recommend It
This carafe offers excellent value with thoughtful design details like drip-resistant pouring and clear markings. It’s a reliable choice for users with mid-range Mr. Coffee models.
Best For
Families or offices using LMX, TP, MMX, or MSX coffee makers who need a durable, user-friendly replacement.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Clear, easy-to-read cup lines
- Minimal dripping during pour
- Good heat retention
- Affordable and widely available
Cons:
- Not compatible with older SK or PLD models
- Handle attachment could be stronger
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Fits perfectly with our Mr. Coffee machine after I accidentally broke the original one that came with the maker. Much easier to replace instead of paying for an entire new machine.”
Customer Review: “This replacement of the pot is perfectly fit, the glass shape is more modern if you like the clean line and straight edge.”
6. 12-Cup Replacement Coffee Carafe Compatible with Mr. Coffee Coffee maker Pot, Replace Part# PLD12…
This versatile Mr Coffee carafe replacement supports a wide array of models including PLD12, AM, CG, CHX, and more. Its adjustable top design allows for flexible fitting, making it a lifesaver for users unsure of exact compatibility.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Fits PLD12, AM, CG, CHX, CJ, DW, DR, EVX, EH, GBX, JWX, KNX, MV, NC, PL, RM, SK, SJ, TF, VB series
✓ Also compatible with select Sunbeam models (6102, 6970, etc.)
✓ Adjustable rim for custom fit
✓ Dishwasher-safe borosilicate glass
✓ Reinforced handle and spout
Why We Recommend It
With its wide compatibility and adaptive design, this carafe is perfect for users who’ve lost their model number or own older machines. It’s a practical, all-in-one solution.
Best For
Owners of older or multi-model households needing a flexible, reliable replacement.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Extremely broad compatibility
- Adjustable fit reduces guesswork
- Durable construction
- Great for emergency replacements
Cons:
- May require minor adjustments for perfect seal
- Slightly heavier than standard carafes
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “This replacement coffee carafe was a virtual lifesaver. I accidentally broke the original carafe and was in a panic because I didn’t have enough money to buy a whole new coffee maker. I was able to buy this replacement coffee carafe and it was truly heaven sent because now I can feel human in the mo”
Customer Review: “I dropped my original carafe. Bought this one and first reaction: ‘OH NO!! It doesn’t fit!!’ But then I saw the adjustable top part. Clipped on a larger top and boom, perfect fit. Coffee, coffee, coffee!!”
7. 12-cup glass coffee carafe replacement for Mr. Coffee LMX, TP, MMX, and MSX series
Crafted specifically for LMX, TP, MMX, and MSX series, this Mr Coffee carafe replacement emphasizes comfort and durability. Its ergonomic handle and non-porous borosilicate glass ensure safe, residue-free brewing every time.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Precision fit for LMX, TP, MMX, MSX models
✓ Made from non-porous, heat-resistant borosilicate glass
✓ Comfort-grip handle with DuraLife reinforcement
✓ Dishwasher-safe and odor-resistant
✓ Smooth pour spout design
Why We Recommend It
This carafe excels in user comfort and long-term hygiene, thanks to its non-stick interior and sturdy build. It’s a smart investment for daily coffee drinkers.
Best For
Daily users of LMX, TP, MMX, or MSX coffee makers who prioritize ease of use and cleanliness.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Excellent grip and balance
- Resists staining and odors
- Easy to pour without spills
- Long-lasting glass clarity
Cons:
- Limited to four model series
- No lid included
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “This replacement coffee carafe was a virtual lifesaver. I accidentally broke the original carafe and was in a panic because I didn’t have enough money to buy a whole new coffee maker. I was able to buy this replacement coffee carafe and it was truly heaven sent because now I can feel human in the mo”
Customer Review: “I dropped my original carafe. Bought this one and first reaction: ‘OH NO!! It doesn’t fit!!’ But then I saw the adjustable top part. Clipped on a larger top and boom, perfect fit. Coffee, coffee, coffee!!”
Complete Buying Guide for Mr Coffee Carafe Replacement
Essential Factors We Consider
When selecting a Mr Coffee carafe replacement, compatibility is the #1 priority. Always verify your coffee maker’s model number (usually found on the bottom or back) before purchasing. Other key factors include glass type (borosilicate is best), handle ergonomics, dishwasher safety, and whether the carafe includes measurement markings. We also evaluate build quality, customer feedback, and value for money to ensure you get a product that lasts.
💡 Related:
Cuisinart coffee maker replacement parts
Budget Planning
Most Mr Coffee carafe replacements range from $15 to $30. While OEM parts may cost more, third-party options often deliver comparable quality at lower prices. Set a budget based on your usage—frequent brewers may want to invest in a premium borosilicate model, while occasional users can opt for budget-friendly alternatives. Remember: a $20 carafe is far cheaper than replacing an entire coffee maker.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right Mr Coffee carafe replacement doesn’t have to be overwhelming. With our expert reviews and compatibility guides, you can confidently restore your coffee maker to full functionality. Whether you prioritize price, fit, or durability, there’s a perfect option on this list for your needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How do I find my Mr. Coffee model number?
A: Check the bottom or back of your coffee maker—it’s usually printed on a label alongside voltage and serial info. Common series include SK, RF, MSX, and PLD.
💡 Related:
Keurig water filter replacements
Q: Can I use any 12-cup glass carafe with my Mr. Coffee machine?
A: No. Not all 12-cup carafes are compatible. Dimensions, handle placement, and rim design vary significantly between models. Always confirm compatibility before buying.
Q: Are these carafes dishwasher safe?
A: Most are top-rack dishwasher safe, but avoid harsh detergents and high heat settings to preserve glass clarity and handle integrity.
Q: What’s the difference between borosilicate and regular glass?
A: Borosilicate glass is more resistant to thermal shock and breakage, making it ideal for hot liquids like coffee. It’s the preferred material for durable carafes.
Q: Do replacement carafes come with lids?
A: Rarely. Most replacements assume you’ll reuse the original lid. If yours is damaged, check if the seller offers a compatible lid separately.
Don’t let a broken carafe ruin your morning routine! With our top-rated Mr Coffee carafe replacements, you can enjoy fresh, hot coffee again in no time. Click any “Check Price” button above to find the perfect match for your machine—and start brewing with confidence today.