A lost or warped crumb tray can turn your trusty toaster oven into a smoky, smelly mess. Whether the original slid out unnoticed during cleanup or simply succumbed to years of baked-on cheese, finding the right toaster oven crumb tray replacement saves you from buying an entirely new appliance. Below, we compare ten of the best-selling trays and liners—ranging from exact-fit stainless-steel models for Ninja Foodi ovens to universal non-stick mats that work in almost any brand—so you can restore a cleaner, safer kitchen in minutes.
Quick Product Comparison
Our Top 10 Toaster Oven Crumb Tray Replacement Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
1. Upgraded SP101 SP100 SP080 Crumb Tray Replacement Part for Ninja Digital Air Fry Oven
Crafted from food-grade 304 stainless steel, this toaster oven crumb tray replacement drops straight into Ninja SP101, SP100, and SP080 series ovens. Precise 13.3″ x 12.8″ dimensions and a mirror finish make cleanup effortless while keeping harmful coatings out of your food.
💡 Related:
air fryer basket replacements
💡 Related:
Ninja air fryer basket replacements
💡 Related:
air fryer tray replacements
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓Exact OEM size for Ninja Digital Air Fry Ovens
- ✓Food-grade 304 stainless steel, BPA-free
- ✓0.22″ rim depth contains grease and crumbs
- ✓Dishwasher-safe and corrosion-resistant
Why We Recommend It
It snaps in place like the original, handles 450°F air-fry cycles without warping, and wipes clean in seconds—no aluminum flakes or non-stick chips to worry about.
Best For
Health-conscious households that want a factory-fresh fit and long-term durability.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Mirror finish releases food instantly
- No sharp edges—safe for kids to handle
- Backed by responsive U.S. customer service
- Will never rust or discolor
Cons:
- Slightly higher price than generic aluminum trays
- Only fits listed Ninja models—check size first
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Perfect fit in my SP101—took 10 seconds to swap. Finally no more smoking crumbs on the heating element.” – Jennifer K.
Customer Review: “Heavy-duty steel, cleans with a quick rinse. Feels sturdier than the tray that came with the oven.” – Mike R.
2. Stainless Steel Crumb Tray Replacement for Ninja Foodi and Toaster Oven Models
Precision-stamped 304 stainless steel gives this toaster oven crumb tray replacement a sturdy 0.3″ rim and a brushed finish that hides fingerprints. Measuring 13.2″ x 12.9″, it aligns with Ninja Foodi SP100/SP101/SP201 and many other toaster ovens that accept a 12.9″-wide tray.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓Brushed 304 stainless steel resists smudges
- ✓Reinforced corners prevent flexing
- ✓Compatible with 111BH300 OEM number
- ✓Oven-, dishwasher-, and freezer-safe
Why We Recommend It
The extra-thick gauge steel distributes heat evenly, so leftover cheese crisps instead of scorching—translation: fewer smoking sessions when you open the door.
Best For
Multitaskers who switch between baking, air-frying, and broiling and need one tray that can take it all.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Brushed surface hides minor scratches
- Deep rim contains bubbling pizza cheese
- Ships in eco-friendly cardboard—no plastic
Cons:
- Edge radius slightly larger than OEM—verify fit
- Heavier than aluminum, so handle with two hands when hot
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Dropped right into my SP201, no wobble. Clean-up is literally a wipe and rinse.” – Tina P.
Customer Review: “Sturdy enough to double as a small baking sheet for fries. Love the brushed look.” – Carlos M.
3. Stainless Steel Crumb Tray Replacement for Ninja Foodi Digital Air Fryer Toaster Oven
Cost-conscious cooks get premium 304 stainless steel at a bargain price. Measuring 13.3″ x 12.8″, this toaster oven crumb tray replacement matches Ninja part #100SG100 and arrives in minimalist recycled packaging that keeps costs low.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓Budget-friendly single-pack option
- ✓Food-grade steel, zero chemical coating
- ✓Fits SP101/SP100/SP201 out of the box
- ✓Lightweight 8-oz design for easy handling
Why We Recommend It
It delivers the same rust-proof performance as higher-priced trays while leaving extra cash in your pocket for coffee beans—or more toaster-oven snacks.
Best For
College dorms, first apartments, or anyone who wants a no-frills OEM-style fix on the cheap.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Lowest price point in stainless-steel category
- Thin profile slides under lower heating elements
- No packaging waste—arrives in paper sleeve
Cons:
- Metal is thinner—may flex when loaded with heavy casseroles
- Brushed grain shows water spots if air-dried
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Five bucks cheaper than the Ninja brand and fits exactly. Great value!” – Lisa H.
Customer Review: “Lightweight but does the job. I bought two so I always have a clean one ready.” – Raj S.
4. Crumb Tray for Ninja Foodi SP101 SP100 SP1001C SP201 Air Fryer, Replacement Tray Pan Parts
Perforated airflow channels set this toaster oven crumb tray replacement apart. The 13.2″ x 12.8″ pan fits Ninja SP100/101/201 and uses tiny vent slots to reduce hot spots, keeping chicken wings crisp on both sides.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓Unique circulation holes for even browning
- ✓Food-grade stainless steel, FDA-compliant
- ✓Raised edges prevent grease spillovers
- ✓Dishwasher-safe heavy-gauge build
Why We Recommend It
If you air-fry often, the perforated pattern keeps air moving underneath food, delivering oven-quality crisp without flipping halfway.
Best For
Air-fry fanatics who hate soggy bottoms on fries or reheated pizza.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Vents eliminate condensation under breaded foods
- Extra-deep 0.4″ rim catches wing drippings
- Steel stays flat at 450°F—no warping
Cons:
- Perforations allow very fine sugar to fall through
- Slightly longer cool-down time due to thermal mass
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “The holes make a real difference—fries come out like restaurant quality. Fits my SP201 perfectly.” – Denise W.
Customer Review: “Sturdy steel, no sharp edges. Cleaning is easy with a soft brush.” – Omar F.